OK. With the lockout going on the draft was a bigger event this year than any other. It’s always big for Browns fans because we’re usually in the top 10 and looking to see how they’ll screw it up. Whether it was seeking out trouble like Gerard Warren or completely wasting the opportunity like trading down 3 times to collect New York Jet also-rans while passing up Mark Sanchez, it always seems to be entertaining and heartbreaking…at least until they hired a real President (Holmgren) and GM (Heckert).
Now it actually seems like they know what they’re doing. Last year, despite criticism, they drafted Joe Haden, Colt McCoy, and TJ Ward, who all became starters that look promising and Montario Hardesty who will be a good RB if he stays healthy. There were some late-round throw away picks that quickly got cut…no surprise there.
So this year we were all excited when the Browns had pick #6 with a front office that knows their stuff. AJ Green, Patrick Peterson, and Marcel Dareus were the guys they were targeting, but the Browns always seem the be the first pick after all their targeted guys get picked. So at the time the city of Cleveland was thinking about Robert Quinn, Nick Fairley, or Julio Jones in a Browns uni.
We were all SHOCKED when it was reported that the Browns traded down…not because they traded down, but because they went from #6 to #27!!!! I was sick at first. That was just too far to go down in the draft for a team that needs elite talent.
After the initial shock, reality set it. “OK. What did we get for trading down? It must have been a haul.” And it was.
For giving the Falcons the #6 pick, the Browns got Atlanta’s #27, 2nd Rd, 4th Rd, 2011 1st Rd, and 2011 4th Rd. That’s pretty good, especially for a team that had major concerns about all the remaining players on the table as far as top 10 grades go, and because they don’t just need one or two guys, but probably 20 guys to turn this team into a winner. Savvy move.
As a result, here’s what they got.
1st Round:
DT Phil Taylor (Baylor) – Who? I watch every college game I can see and never heard of this guy. He was a 5 star recruit to Penn St., got in a little trouble and transferred to Baylor, where he was the only good player on a shitty Baylor team. He had high grades among all NFL teams and is an absolute LOAD that will anchor the D line along with Rubin. Not a flashy pick, but played about 80 snaps/game compared to Fairley’s 25. He’ll play and stuff the run, which the Browns have historically been awful at. With no other DT of this caliber left in the draft, they made a smart move instead of the flashy one.
Grade: A-
2nd Round:
DE Jabaal Sheard (Pitt). Who? the Big East defensive players of the year, that’s who. Learned to play DE under Dave Wannstedt, who know a few things about defense. On the lighter side at 255 lbs, but that is how Heckert likes his DEs…fast to the QB. Sheard was a sack machine at Pitt and will be a true edge rusher that the Browns haven’t had in a while. Again not flashy…but talented and under the radar.
Grade: A-
WR Greg Little (UNC). Who? Well, he isn’t as anonymous as the others, but did not play this year after gathering a suspension as part of UNC’s NCAA problems from last year. Little is a freak of an athlete who is big, fast, and has great hands. Had he played this season he may have been picked about Julio Jones, so this is a steal of a pick. He’s a perfect fit for the West Coast offense with his catch and run ability and a high ceiling guy that will probably start and contribute big time.
Grade: A+
3rd Round:
Pick traded to KC in order to move up from 27 to 21 to pick Taylor
4th Round:
TE Jordan Cameron (USC). Who? He didn’t play that much and had a total of 18 catches last year for the Trojans, but another freak athlete who will be a project at TE in the mold of Antonio Gates. He was a college basketball player before deciding he’d rather play football, so he’s a little raw. He’s definitely not going to be a typical TE that blocks 80% of the time. He’s going to be a receiving TE who will be an instant mismatch with LB’s. Some risk with this pick, but another high ceiling talent, so worthy of a 4th Rd pick.
Grade: B+
FB Owen Marecic (Stanford). Who? This guy we know. He was the only two way player in college last year, playing both FB and LB. He will strictly be a FB for the Browns. This pick is solid as Marecic is a just football player, but a little curious because the Browns have one of the best in Lawrence Vickers. But Vickers is a free agent and the Browns may not want to pay a blocking FB $3M when the West Coast offense requires a FB that can block and be a receiver. The Browns had bigger needs than FB, so this was questionable.
Grade: C
5th Round:
CB Buster Skrine (Tenn-Chatt). Who? Well, that’s a valid question. Basically he got drafted because he ran a 4.22 40-yd dash. He can absolutely FLY, but was inconsistent as a CB. This is clearly a project that could have a big upside with his speed. Probably a backup or nickel back at best, but will be a gunner on special teams. It’s the 5th Rd, after all.
Grade: C
OT Jason Pinkston (Pitt). Who? Another Pitt guy. Clearly Heckert got some real good info on these guys after interviewing Dave Wannstedt for the DC position. Pinkston played OT and may be able to play that position in the NFL, but he is probably more likely to be an OG. This is another solid player and developmental pick, but the Browns did not get a true OT, which is what they really need.
Grade: B-
7th Round:
S Eric Hagg (Nebraska). Who? Well, he’s a hitter, not a cover guy, but this smells of a special teams guy. Not someone who will ever play Safety. This was a compensatory pick and it looks like they were on autodraft.
Grade: ?? Who the hell knows with a 7th Rounder.
Fans must remember that this draft will not be truly complete until we see who the Browns pick with Atlanta’s 1st Rd pick next year. The players they got were needed and all solid to very good players, which is what is needed to build a team. Little may be the only future pro-bowl candidate, but that is fine. You can reasonably expect to see most of these guys be productive players for several years.
Final Verdict: I’m giving this draft an A- overall. The actual players they picked would grade out at a B, but the fact that they got 2 additional picks in this draft and two additional next year, including a 1st Rd. pick, makes this draft very good for the franchise in turning things around.




